[s2e17] Careful What You Wish For May 2026

: Critics highlight Chimney's growth and the heartbreaking performance by Ryan Guzman (Eddie) during Shannon’s death scene.

: Some viewers found the "Be Careful What You Wish For" theme a bit heavy-handed—notably a lottery winner driven to suicide and a woman hit by a mail bomb. However, reviewers at Telltale TV noted that the "messy" leadership transition for Chimney felt realistic and kept the narrative engaging. [S2E17] Careful What You Wish For

Reviews generally praise the episode for its emotional weight but acknowledge its "downer" nature: : Critics highlight Chimney's growth and the heartbreaking